Pete Rates the Propositions
Sensible opinions on the California ballot propositions      since 1980      by Pete Stahl

Home
 
Read the ratings:
Prop. 1A - YES
Prop. 1B - NO
Prop. 1C - NO
Prop. 1D - YES
Prop. 1E - YES
Prop. 1F - NO
 
Election resources
 
About the author
Best of Pete Rates
Past results
Contact Pete
 
Previous elections:
November 2008
June 2008
February 2008
November 2006
June 2006
November 2005
November 2004
March 2004
October 2003
November 2002
more...

Special Election on May 19th

Pete StahlHey, voters!

Pursuant to the resolution (or not) of the budget stalemate, there will be a special statewide election on Tuesday, May 19th. Six ballot propositions await your judgment.

The first five, numbered 1A through 1E, relate directly to state finances and deserve serious consideration. In my opinion, they are a mixed bag; I'm recommending "yes" votes on three of them and "no" on two. Please take a look at my ratings for details.

The sixth, Prop 1F, is a ridiculous and feeble pot shot at the Legislature, apparently intended to let voters vent their fury at the budget mess. I may be the only person in the state who opposes Prop 1F, but oppose it I do. It will solve nothing and further poison the atmosphere.

As I was browsing the Secretary of State's Web site on a late-February Sunday afternoon, I noticed that she had given the public a scant one business day to prepare arguments for the ballot pamphlet. This is also ridiculous and feeble. Nevertheless, I had a few spare hours, so I threw together a case against Prop 1F and faxed it in. Much to my surprise, my submission was accepted, and now appears in the official Voter Information Guide. I hope you enjoy it and take it for what it's worth.

It will be fun to see whether this results in any notoriety. The Sacramento Bee ran an article painting me in rather Quixotic hues, which predictably elicited a storm of derision from the anonymous trolls on their bulletin board. The Christian Science Monitor, on the other hand, was very fair and polite, and the hot blogs Calbuzz and America's Finest Blog were downright complimentary.

I'm hoping this is just a sideshow, though, because the coverage really ought to go to Props 1A through 1E, which are actually meaningful.

Happy voting,
Pete Stahl

 
 
 
Copyright © 1980-2009 Peter L. Stahl
Your comments are welcome at pete@peterates.com